What Happens After a Domestic Violence Restraining Order Is Filed Against You in California
A domestic violence restraining order is a serious matter with immediate consequences for the person named in the restraining order. California law treats circumstances involving domestic violence with extreme seriousness.
Initially, a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) is filed and entered into a statewide database. This means every law enforcement agency in the state can enforce the restraining order as soon as the restrained person is served.
From this point forward, a person served with a Restraining Order must be intentional about how they proceed. In family law, a Domestic Violence Restraining Order is among the most serious and restrictive restraining orders.
What is the Purpose and Effect of a Domestic Violence Restraining Order?
A Domestic Violence Restraining Order’s (DVRO) purpose is to protect an abuse victim from future incidents of harm. However, these restraining orders can also be abused or even weaponized in family law cases.
For example, in a contentious child custody case, a parent may seek a restraining order against the other without cause to gain an advantage in custody negotiations.
An individual accused of domestic violence can have their entire life turned upside down in a moment. Domestic abuse includes not only physical violence between spouses but also stalking, verbal threats, and manipulation. Because a restraining order is often issued without the accused even being heard, the restrained person must develop a plan to address the order quickly.
What Legal Elements Are Part of a Domestic Violence Restraining Order?
First, the relationship between the party seeking the protective order and the restrained person must be domestic in nature. Much like how the definition of domestic abuse is broadly defined, so too is the definition of what constitutes a domestic relationship. Under the law, current spouses, former spouses, and parents of a shared child are all in domestic relationships.
From there, there are three important elements of a domestic violence restraining order that must be considered in detail:
- The restrained person’s intent is not relevant when considering a restraining order. For instance, the individual listed as the accused in the restraining order need not have intended to harm the protected individual. As long as the accused’s actions caused the protected person to feel afraid, distressed, or otherwise harassed, the application for a restraining order may succeed.
- A restraining order may be based on one or multiple events. Typically, a pattern or series of bad actions matters more to a judge when considering whether to grant the motion for a protective order.
- A protective order may be expanded to include minor children if a judge determines that a child was present at the time abuse occurred or if their well-being is in danger moving forward.
What Type of Protective Orders Are Available in California?
Law enforcement issues Emergency Protective Orders in situations that require immediate protection for an individual. Judges can approve an emergency protective order by phone. To renew or challenge these protective orders, a party must convert them into a Temporary Restraining Order.
Temporary Restraining Orders require the petitioning party to submit paperwork. Importantly, a judge may grant a petition for a temporary restraining order without first hearing from the accused individual.
Temporary restraining orders can prohibit contact between the parties, remove an accused from a family home, and prevent the accused from attending school or other events where children are present. Most temporary restraining orders last about 25 days, which is long enough for a court to schedule a hearing where all parties can submit evidence on whether to extend the order.
Finally, a permanent restraining order can last up to five years. Courts may issue these protective orders only after a hearing in which both sides can present evidence and arguments to persuade the judge. The court must determine that not only did domestic abuse occur, but that it is likely to happen again.
How to Respond When a Domestic Violence Restraining Order is Filed Against You
Responding to a domestic violence restraining order that has been filed against you takes intentionality and planning. You can go through this process without a plan, but it is not advisable. Rather, once a domestic violence restraining order has been filed, the process of notifying you of its existence will already be underway.
The opposing party will have filed the restraining order and must now have you served with notice of its filing. California law provides that a responding party has the right to be personally served with the restraining order. The paperwork in this package will include a notice of the hearing date, including the time and location.
The court will typically set a hearing on the matter within 21 days. This 21-day d waiting period allows both parties an opportunity to prepare their cases. This includes identifying witnesses and preparing to cross-examine the opposing party’s witnesses. What Must Be Proved: Protective Orders Hearing?
A preponderance of the evidence must convince a judge that the petitioner’s position is true. Essentially, if the judge finds it more likely than not that the events in question occurred, the application for the domestic violence protective order will be approved.
Respondents in a Domestic Violence Protective Order Hearing Are at a Disadvantage
Simply put, the responding party in a domestic violence protective order hearing is at somewhat of a disadvantage as a result of this lower threshold for proving that the events in question occurred. There need not be any history of criminal charges or convictions, nor any tangible evidence to substantiate the petitioner’s story. Fairly weak evidence can sustain an application for a protective order.
The main weapon a responding party has to counter the petitioner’s advantages is to cross-examine the petitioner’s witnesses effectively. When the petitioner makes a claim in the protective order hearing, the ability to cross-examine the witness becomes critical. This cross-examination period allows a judge to assess the truthfulness and authenticity of the witnesses’ stories.
What Steps Should a Responding Party Take After Being Served with a Protective Order?
It can come as a complete shock when a person is served with a domestic violence restraining order. However, there is no room to jump to conclusions or worry excessively. Instead, devising a plan and executing it intentionally are critical to a responding party’s success.
A responding party should read the protective order. Even if the allegations are false or exaggerated, the party must follow it. Violating the temporary restraining order is not an option. The consequences for each violation are severe. By the time a person is served with notice of a hearing, only a week or two likely remains before the order’s viability period ends and a hearing must be held.
The state of California allows a respondent to file a written response once served with a domestic violence protective order. While this response likely won’t be the only evidence a judge considers, a respondent can use it as the basis for the rest of their arguments.
When a Domestic Violence Protective Order is Filed Against You
Make no mistake, even when no criminal charges are filed against a responding party, a domestic violence protective order is a serious situation. First, your freedom of movement, typically enjoyed in California and the United States, will generally be curtailed. A responding party cannot contact the petitioner and must not go to that person’s home, place of employment, or a child’s school.
Violating any term of the protective order means the respondent will likely face contempt of court and ultimately criminal charges. Even a small violation of a protective order can result in an arrest.
Moving forward, the protective order may affect child custody and visitation orders. Supervised visitation may be necessary to protect the children, especially if they are named in the protective order.
Contact Gilligan, Frisco, Trutanich & Saris, LLP, today for a Free Case Review
A domestic violence protective order is a serious situation to face without experienced California family law attorneys. Contact Gilligan, Frisco, Trutanich & Saris, LLP today for a free consultation. Our legal team can answer your questions and provide an overview of a protective order case tailored to your specific circumstances.