Divorce Mediation vs. Going to Court: A California Couple’s Guide to Choosing the Right Path
Deciding how to get divorced is as tough as deciding to get divorced in the first place. Once the decision to move forward is made, the next question is how to finalize the divorce.
In California, couples have two options: mediation or litigation (going to court). Both have specific advantages and disadvantages to consider.
The nature of marital disagreements, whether children are involved, and the division of property are critical components of a divorce. The couple’s specific circumstances will determine the direction the divorce takes.
What is Mediation in a California Divorce?
Mediation involves two spouses working with a third-party mediator to settle through negotiation. Issues related to marital property division, post-divorce spousal support, and child custody are addressed.
It is essential to note that the mediator does not make decisions for either spouse during the mediation session. Rather, the mediator is neutral, favoring neither party and acting as a facilitator. Instead, they guide spouses toward an amicable settlement.
Many spouses who have participated in mediation will recall that the most significant advantage is control over the process. Personalized settlement outcomes tailored to their needs are prioritized.
This is a collaborative setting where the spouses keep control over negotiations and work together to solve problems. Additionally, mediation is quicker and less expensive than litigation, which is undoubtedly a positive aspect.
Can I Be Represented During Mediation?
Some spouses worry about legal representation during mediation. The relaxed nature of mediation should not lead anyone to believe that no representation is available. There is a range of representation options available for a spouse during the mediation process. Options include having an attorney attend mediation to offer advice or hiring an attorney to review a settlement agreement before signing.
How Does Mediation Typically Occur?
Mediation may be completed in as little as one day. Alternatively, the parties may schedule multiple mediation sessions over the course of many days. It all depends upon the complexity of the divorce and the positions taken by the spouses.
The first step involved in a successful mediation for divorcing spouses is to collect and exchange information related to finances and the children. Income, expenses, assets, debts, and child-related information may be exchanged informally or through the Discovery process.
The negotiation process begins in earnest once the mediator has helped the parties identify the most contentious areas of their case. Developing a parenting plan, child custody schedule, and child support payments is contentious for many families. As a result, mediators tend to focus their time on those subjects. Community property division and separate property determination dominate discussions on the property side of divorce negotiations.
Confidentiality: A Benefit of Mediation
One of the benefits of mediation that is often overlooked concerns the confidentiality of the proceedings. Because mediation is informal, settlement negotiations are kept confidential, and the parties’ positions cannot be used against each other if the case proceeds to litigation.
If a settlement is reached, the mediator prepares a marital settlement agreement. The parties sign the agreement, and it is sent to the court for filing. This settlement agreement determines the final terms of a divorce. In as few as one session, but often in a series of settlement negotiations spread out over a few months, these mediation settings can help resolve a divorce amicably.
Divorce Litigation: Going to Court
When most people think about resolving a contentious divorce, it is likely the backdrop of a courtroom. The litigation process begins with the filing of a divorce petition. Once the petition is filed, the filing spouse will have it served on the other party. They can review the petition and will likely file a response.
In California, divorcing spouses must exchange financial documents disclosing assets, debts, and property-related matters. If necessary, the spouses may choose to go a step further and exchange discovery responses. These are formal requests for documents, written questions, and other methods of obtaining information.
Temporary orders may be requested during the pending divorce case. These temporary orders help parties divide custody and financial responsibility for the children. Regarding property, temporary orders establish which spouse has control over which property and assets during the divorce. Clear expectations and rights reduce the likelihood of disagreements and acrimony during an already stressful divorce process.
When Mediation Fails, Litigation Follows
The litigation process begins with the filing of a divorce petition. Even participants in a divorce proceeding have the opportunity to settle their case through mediation. Attorneys counsel their clients that their case will proceed to trial unless they can set aside their differences and work toward a middle ground.
The longer a divorce case proceeds, the faster expenses, fees, and court costs add up. A longer divorce, especially one that goes to trial, costs the parties more money. In some circumstances, this may be an unavoidable reality. Spouses often hold disparate views, convinced there’s no middle ground to negotiate.
What Are the Main Differences Between Mediation and Litigation in a California Divorce?
Let’s break down the key differences between divorce mediation and litigation:
- Time is a precious and irreplaceable resource. Mediated cases in California can wrap up in as little as six months, the minimum time for a California divorce. Litigated divorces, on the other hand, can take up to 12 months or longer.
- Mediated divorces are significantly less costly. The exact costs of divorce cases vary depending on several factors, but generally speaking, a litigation-based divorce will cost more than a mediated divorce.
- In mediation, spouses have more control over the outcome. A mediator facilitates information exchange, not advising or making decisions. This contrasts with a judge, who makes decisions in a litigated divorce. Even spouses with stark disagreements can often settle on better terms than a judge who knows them little.
What Kind of Divorce is Better Suited for Mediation?
Spouses who can set aside their differences and work with a third-party mediator tend to do better in mediation. Many spouses are aware that a divorce is a temporary stage in their lives. However, the money spent on a divorce is not coming back. By combining this awareness with the ability to keep costs low, many would benefit from a mediated divorce.
One of the most difficult aspects of a divorce is crafting a parenting plan that suits both parents and, most importantly, fosters a relationship between the children and both parents. In a trial, a judge may make a decision that suits neither party well. In contrast, a mediated divorce allows both parents to negotiate a parenting plan directly.
How to Determine When Litigation is Needed in a California Divorce?
When there’s a significant power imbalance between spouses, a trial becomes a more attractive option for the less powerful spouse. A spouse who’s been a victim of domestic violence or similar abuse should prepare their case for court as soon as possible.
Contact Gilligan, Frisco, Trutanich & Sarris LLP for a Free Case Review
The outcome of your divorce case matters. Don’t entrust your relationship with your children, livelihood, and property to just any lawyer. Contact Gilligan, Frisco, Trutanich & Sarris LLP for a free case review. Our team of California family law attorneys takes its responsibility to serve divorcing spouses.